
Since signing with the Yankees in 2002, Matsui averaged 20 home runs, 140 hits, 28 doubles, and 85 RBI per season, while batting .292, with a slugging percentage of .482 and an on-base percentage of .370. What’s more, besides the 2006 and 2008 seasons, when injuries limited him to 51 and 93 games, respectively, Matsui played in no less than 142 games, and drove in no fewer than 90 runs in any given season. It’s one thing to be consistent, quite another to be consistently good—and an almost impossible feat to be consistently good in New York without falling prey to the non-stop yammering of modern sports talk radio.
In sports, you see, there’s always a nauseating amount of talk about whether or not a player is underrated or overrated. Adrian Gonzalez, for instance, or Robinson Cano, can be argued either way, depending on the person or the preferred statistic of the day. Matsui, though, is the rare athlete, the rare New York athlete, valued by fans and baseball people alike at a worth equal to that of his talents.
During his tenure with the Yankees, Matsui played like a professional, and was always appreciated as such.